We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
other travellers have booked this property

Sag Harbor with perfect water view and sunset

Historic whaling captains home, walking distance from the village of Sag Harbor
Very good
3 reviews
Historic whaling captains home, walking distance from the village of Sag Harbor
Every evening the sun puts on a lightshow over the water.
Enjoy the water and dock, or take a nap in the hammock.
Idyllic place for a quiet afternoon or evening
Enjoy breakfast on the large porch
This second floor bed room overlooks the cove.
This second floor bedroom overlooks the harbor
This third floor room overlooks the cove.
This third floor room overlooks the harbor
The living room has portraits of Charles Payne and his wife Marie, who built the house in 1832
The dining room is the second best place to eat breakfast, after the porch.
An office that connects the two second floor rooms
The second floor bathroom
The third floor bathroom
This property is not available for these dates.
Don't give up! Enquire about other rentals just like this one that are available -
Show all rentals available
Private Room , 2 Bathrooms , Sleeps 7
Sag Harbor, Long Island, New York
Historic whaling captains home. We are the sixth generation to live here. It is a quick walk from our house to the village of Sag Harbor, where you will find restaurants, boutiques, antique stores, marinas and much more. If you wish to stay around the house, we have a dock, hammock and the best porch in the world. Sit on the porch swing and watch the sunset over the cove.
We have bicycles, small sailboats and a kayak available for our guests. There is plenty of parking, and you are welcome to leave your car here and explore without the hassle of parking. You can even walk to the Hampton Jitney stop and forget driving all weekend.
We are offering four bedrooms in a separate wing of the house. Most bedrooms have a water view. Two bedrooms, each with a double bed, share a bathroom on the second floor, and two bedrooms, with 3 single...
Read more
Listing #FKN6770539
About the Owner
Ann S
Response Rate:100%
Response Time:Within a few hours
Interaction with guests
My family is available to answer questions. I will be here to check you in and show you the house. I usually make sure things are going well at breakfast, but otherwise do not see our guests.
Reviews from our community
Write a ReviewReviews (3)

1 - 3 of 3 reviews

Reviewed 17 July 2017 via mobile

My family have just spent 7 days at a charming whaling cottage in Sag Harbor.The position to town was great and the tranquility of the home was ideal.The owners Anne and Dave went out of their way to help and make our stay great.I recommend...More

Thank kpsaccuzzo
Reviewed 8 July 2016

Ann and Dave offer this lovely, historic home to guests and provide everything needed for a wonderful stay. The porch overlooking the water is heavenly. You really feel like you are away from it all. Yet, a five minute walk has you in the heart...More

Thank rosewalsh2016
Management response:Responded 9 July 2016

Thanks Rose. We enjoyed hosting your family and look forward to Patricia's return next month. It was fun seeing you and your sisters enjoy the porch in the same way I do with my sisters. Ann

See more reviews
Reviewed 12 June 2016

My family and I (six people) stayed in this lovingly cared for home while attending a wedding. I can truly say that we were delighted with the accomodations and the warm, welcoming family that maintains this historic home. We immediately added an extra night to...More

1  Thank eweaver_12
Management response:Responded 12 June 2016

Thank you Ellen. We look forward to your return in October. Ann

  • Air Conditioning
  • Cable/satellite TV
  • Central Heating
  • Double Beds:(2)
  • Full Baths (2)
  • Internet Access
  • Linens Provided
  • Living Room Seats (9)
  • Ocean Views
  • Outdoor Dining Area
  • Porch
  • Safe
  • Secure Parking
  • Single Beds:(3)
  • Towels Provided
  • Waterfront
  • Water Views
  • Wi-Fi
House rules
    Not kid-friendly
    Pets not allowed
    Smoking not allowed
    Check in: 3:00 PM
    2 Full baths
    2 Fulls
    3 Twins
Show Rates

Rates are calculated based on the latest information provided. Please contact the manager/owner to confirm actual rates for your requested dates.

Select the number of guests
Dates Min stay Weeknight Weekend night
Default 2 nights
USD 600
USD 650
Please note: rates may have been converted from the original local currency to Australian Dollars and are approximate rates that may change due to exchange rate fluctuation. Please contact the manager to confirm actual rates for your requested dates.
  • Damage Deposit: AU$677 / stay - Deposit
Hide Rates
About the neighbourhood
Sag Harbor has always been a unique place in the Hamptons. Formerly one of the largest Whaling ports on the East Coast. As East Hampton and Southampton became the playgrounds of the wealthy, Sag Harbor remained a small village, with a 5 and 10, hardware store, grocery store and movie theater all reminiscent of a simpler time. These stores still remain, but the glamour and bustle of Hamptons have moved to Main Street, with many specialty boutiques. You can choose between many restaurants that run the gambit from the five star American Hotel or Beacon, to the casual burger at LT, or a slice of pizza at Conca D'oro. Finding a wonderful meal is easy. The nightlife is just a varied. You can enjoy the local theater, a movie, bars, or people watch on Main Street while eating some of ou... more
Getting around
The easiest way to explore Sag Harbor is to walk. Our family rarely drives to the village - it is just easier to walk and avoid the parking hassles. A car is handy is you want to visit Montauk, the ocean, or the Hampton villages. We have bikes if you wish to explore outside of town, but it is a sunny ride to the ocean and can be hot.
Car not needed
How to get there
Railway: LIRR Bridgehampton: 8.0 km
The Hampton Jitney runs multiple buses every day from Manhattan to Sag Harbor. It is a five minute walk over the bridge to our house.
Activities nearby
There Is A Golf Course Within 30 Mins Drive, Horse Riding Nearby, There Are Tennis Courts Nearby, Nearest Beach: 1.5 km.
About this property
How do I know if the property is available?
First, check the Availability tab on this page to see if your dates are available. If they are, contact the owner via the TripAdvisor Rental Inbox to confirm availability.
How can I contact the owner?
Initially, you may contact the owner via the TripAdvisor Rental Inbox. This inbox is created after you send your first message or booking request to the owner. After you've made your first payment, you'll be able to see the owner's contact information.
How will the owner contact me?
This owner will contact you via the TripAdvisor Rental Inbox.
What if I don't hear back from the owner?
You can send another message via the TripAdvisor Rental Inbox to ask if the property is still available.
How do I pay?
For this property, please use a credit card to pay via the TripAdvisor Rental Inbox. Once the owner approves your stay, he or she will send you a quote, which will include payment instructions.
Is my payment insured in any way?
Yes. Payments made via the TripAdvisor inbox are covered by our Peace of Mind Protection.
Do you own a holiday rental? List it here.
Extra income
Earn money by renting out your home. With no up-front fees and no contract, you keep more for yourself.
Easy to manage
Confirm bookings in one click and track everything from enquiry to check-out – even while you're on the go.
Trusted by travellers
With millions of reviews and protected online payments, TripAdvisor helps travellers book your home with confidence.
Set up your free listing
Enter dates for more accurate prices
2 guests