The "Double Decker Pizza Pie" is in the top 5 pizzas we have ever tasted. Living just south of Chicago this is pretty impressive in my eyes.
We also had a couple other pizzas, and a calzone during our stay on the island. Everything was delicious and always hot and fresh (of course we ate at the Thirsty Turtle just steps away).
Our family is a "could eat pizza 7 days a week" kinda family and this was definitely a quality pie!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.