We finally made our first trip to Door County last year (July 2014). My husband and I had gotten up very early that morning and went for a very long hike. We were traveling back to Egg Harbor and happened upon this place. The adorable blue building with sunshine on it's sign was inviting. We walked inside and were greeted by two very friendly staff members and seated immediately. The wait was short and what happened next was amazing. My taste buds water as I write this..Colonel Mustard in the White House- oven roasted potatoes crowned with sauteed mushrooms, ham, onions, swiss cheese, and topped with our famous mustard cream sauce. That is what I had and to this date I try to copycat this at home. We went back in October and brought our daughter and my mother in law. Same fairytale experience and I do not know how to try anything else as this is my favorite. My husband had the whitefish sandwich and that was great too.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.