If you are looking for good pizza in Sheboygan, Fayes is the place to go. Although it is so small, that if you aren't looking you will drive right past it, don't! This little gem has won the award for the best pizza in town for years and for good reason-it's delicious! We always get their thin crust pizza and since we can't agree on toppings, they will make half and half. The crust is crisp, the sauce is flavorful and the cheese is melted deliciousness. We also get the garlic cheesebread, which I could eat as my meal. Usually, there are young kids working and they are friendly and fun. The atmosphere is casual pizzeria-nothing fancy here. They do serve Italian meals such as baked zitl and spaghetti and meatballs but I love the pizza so much I have never tried anything else. I highly recommend Fayes.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.