Every year we stay in a house on Poteskeet and this bakery is at the end of our road. We have never bought anything in Tullio's until this year. After dinner out we stopped in to get dessert to take home and have later. We got one piece of key lime pie and one piece of southern pecan pie. Both were delicious. I see lots of bad reviews about the cakes, but we didn't have any of those. Everything in the display counter looks wonderful and they have the biggest selection of biscotti I have ever seen anywhere. I would go back for more pie, and would try some biscotti and bagels, but I think I'll stay away from the cakes. I did think the prices were a little high compared to what I am used to at home. Each pie was $6, which is higher than most restaurant prices for pie... Also, the person behind the counter never greeted us or acted like he really cared that we were there.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.