I have been going to Hoffmans for over 25 years, and it is still the best ice cream in New Jersey. As you have read, they get very busy on the weekends, especially in the evenings. There is a reason for that. The ice cream is that good!. Is the place messy, with dirty floors or sticky tables on the weekends, especially in the evenings, yes. But honestly, people, is that so unreasonable. Are your standards so high that you would not enjoy the ice cream because there were napkins on the floor? Insane! Let it go, or go there on a Tuesday afternoon where you will find a well maintained interior. And if that just doesnt work for you, then eat in your car or get it to go like 85% of everyone else. It's ice cream folks. not Christies Steakhouse.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.