My family and I truly love eating there, and while 1 of our 4 little boys may provide a little entertainment for this small, quaint, old-school style pizzeria, the owner, managers, wait staff is just the best. They have offered coloring pages, little toys, and spend some time talking to the kids. Eating out for a family of 6 isn't affordable in today's day and age, and while Bloomingdale isn't the most affordable pie, their quality and their genuine kind and caring attitude is spot-on consistent coupled with delicious pizza. Perfectly baked and tasty crust, NY style, good sauce and cheese and good toppings.
We also have one very difficult eater, and even if he doesn't eat pizza, this is one of the few places we can always get him to eat. Bloomingdale Pizza also has the only thing around that's similar to the northern style sheet pizzas, so it's great for parties. I've literally picked up pizzas from here with all 4 of my boys (still in car seats) and these guys always offer to carry the food out to the van for us. It's rare to see a place with that many genuinely nice staff members.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.