Vacationing on Siesta Key or nearby? We are, and we've found G's has good pizza for a fair price. The owner has been nice both times we've visited (two different vacations), even giving us coupon discounts without a coupon.
It won't be the best pizza in your life, it'll be FAR from the worst, but it'll be good, hot and filling. Isn't that what it's all about? Get it to go, since the shop isn't anything fancy. Try the BBQ Chicken pizza. It's quite good.