One of our favorite restaurants in Marathon when we are visiting. We found this place 7 years ago when on vacation and loved the food and experience and we can gladly say that it is still holding up. My kids love the honey buns and it is one of their favorite meals and a must eat place when we are in Marathon. I had fresh lobster that was cooked perfectly and a very good portion. The vegetables were also delicious that were served with the lobster.
My wife always gets their peel and eat shrimp because they are delicious and all an individual can eat. Our server was very friendly and accommodating as we asked several times for different sauces for our lobster and shrimp and he brought them quickly.
Castaways also has an extensive beer menu and I had two delicious beers that I had not seen in other restaurants in the Keys. This is a fun restaurant that is a bit off the beaten path but well worth the visit.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.