I stayed on Big Pine and was looking for a place that was open later in the evening and stumbled upon Bucktooth Rooster. I was in the mood for seafood and was happy to see they had conch fritters and a variety of seafood items. Their fritters were a great appetizer, for my main meal I ordered the Fresh Catch Sandwich. The sandwich was amazing. It consisted of a whole fillet, I could have easily made two sandwiches with it. The taste of the batter was phenomenal, definitely two thumbs up! My girlfriend ordered the seafood quesadilla and that was very good as well. The atmosphere was cozy and the service was good. I highly recommend coming here, but come hungry because the portions are huge!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.