I was in the mood for some awesome pie so I checked places in Greeley that mentioned having handmade pie. Some of the photos of their pie looked great, so I took a chance and ordered a piece of coconut cream pie to go. It was truly awful. The crust was missing except for the bottom, and that was really soggy. The filling, which should be light and creamy, was dense and hard and congealed. There was also the taste of co-mingled foods from the cooler which leads me to believe the pie was definitely not freshly baked . What a huge disappointment for my first time to this restaurant. And to top it off, the price was really high for a small piece of pie....$6.69.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.