Let me start by telling you that this review is for the dining room only, not the accommodations.
We have family in the area and they had called to make reservations in the dining room specifically. They were told not a problem, check in at the bar also attached to the Hotel and we would be seated in the dining room. We did that and were told to take a seat and they would be right with us.
Here is where the 15 minute journey starts. We took a seat, waited and waited and waited some more. While we were waiting for menus and someone to simply bring water, Mr. B cleaned cob webs off the tablecloth and Uncle B, blew dust out of his water glass. We continued to wait, still no one showed up. About 15 minutes in to our waiting, a man comes out of the kitchen, sweaty and wearing a white tank shirt. He asks if we have been helped, we tell him no, but we did check in at the bar and someone was suppose to be coming. He grunts, Ok and goes back in the kitchen. We waited a few more minutes and just couldn't take it any longer, with the dirty tableclothes, dust in the glasses and lack of any kind of service, we leave and wander down to Coulter Cafe.
While we waited, two other couples came in and waited for someone to help them, when they got no assistance, they too walked out. It really is a shame, it is a cool spot with a lot of history.
Save yourself and do not eat at Hotel Jeffrey.