Family of 4 stayed 2 nights and this was a great location for our time in Reykjavik. You are right on the main street for shops and there is free parking at the church. The apartment is spacious and the kitchen and bathroom were both very nice.
Do note that you need to be able to climb stairs, as there is no elevator.
The perfect base to explore a beautiful city and further afield. Apartment was warm, tasteful and quiet - no worries about street noise. Key exchange and booking process very straightforward and owner quick to respond to queries. The rooms are large and felt airy thanks to high ceilings and big windows, but with underfloor heating in kitchen/bathroom and good heating throughout it always felt cosy, even in January. Great to have a luxurious bathtub after days out exploring on tired feet. Area felt safe and Icelanders very friendly and helpful. In short, it was perfect. We have many happy memories of our trip - thanks Rannveig!