Our party of 3 people absolutely loved the Bar George dinner experience. The surroundings are elegant and beautiful, not to mention fun and quirky (such as using curling stones as door stops!).
The staff (waiters, maitre d', and coat check) was most respectful, attentive, and helpful. The food (appetizers, main dishes, and dessert) was both inventive and top notch, all with the correct flavour balance. Apparently, only two restaurants serve beef wellington in Montreal and this is one of them. The beef was cooked in such a way that it melts in the mouth while the puff pastry was obviously made on site instead of supplier bought.
The prices may look up there but in terms of what you get back for it (the overall experience), it is well worth a visit to Bar George.