We visited Water Island during our cruise in February. I would probably not recommend this as a day trip from the cruise boats unless your time frame is pretty wide. We had to wait about an hour for the ferry which wasn't a big deal because we just had some beers at the bar while waiting. Once on the island we walked to honeymoon beach. The beach was beautiful and the water was nice. We found a ton of sea glass and had a nice lunch. The downside like everyone else has mentioned is that the party boats arrive at about noon and are very noisy and rude. We had about an hour of peace before they arrived and it was great. Then they get there, are super loud and obnoxious. I have to say it sort of ruined the experience. If you can get there and out before they show up I would highly recommned it. Make sure to check the ferry schedule.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.