We've seen the one star review in Italian and understood parts of it.
Yes, the villa is small, but we were 7 people and were perfectly comfortable.
This is not a plush modern villa, it is a comfortable friendly beautiful place with a great view on a lovely island.
I would have liked a better barbecue and a bigger bathroom, but the pool was marvellous and the terrace at breakfast time was ideal.
For the price this is great value and we are going again!!!