Capri Palace Vs Luxury Villa Excelsior, which one is better?

Dearest All,

I will be staying with my parents and my nephew and sisters.

I am in confuse with this two properties. The Capri Palace is seems more modern and bigger. But has more complain review.

The villa excelsior has more good review but old and small.

this is my first time to Capri and I have no idea where to stay better for first timer.

The price differences between two is not much during the day I am staying.

Any advice?

thank you