I'm planning our first vacay to Cat Island. So excited but so much to learn beforehand. I'm tentatively looking at a private rental for a large group of us down at the southeast tip of the island, It appears that there isn't really a bad choice on Cat Island, but I don't want to screw up. For you veterans and long-time C.I. visitors, do you have or can you recommend a preferred location? Off the beaten path of course is always a good thing, but I don't want to be isolated from nearby restaurants, bars, and of course beautiful beaches. So Arthur's Town, New Bight, Old Bight? Ocean side or the calm water side? Much appreciated!