We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Restaurants in Shelter Island

View map
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Reservations
Online Bookings
Cuisines & Dishes
(33)
(18)
(4)
Austrian
(1)
Bar
(24)
(16)
Central American
(1)
Contemporary
(2)
(8)
Diner
(3)
(2)
(1)
(1)
Grill
(2)
(4)
(9)
Pub
(11)
(4)
Southwestern
(1)
(3)
Bagels
(1)
Baguette
(3)
Burrito
(4)
Ceviche
(2)
Cheeseburger
(1)
Cheesecake
(2)
Cheesesteak
(1)
Chowder
(1)
Corned Beef
(1)
Crab
(17)
Crab Cake
(6)
Falafel
(1)
Filet Mignon
(2)
Fish & Chips
(7)
Fish Taco
(9)
French Toast
(1)
Frozen Yogurt
(2)
Gyros
(1)
Halloumi
(1)
Hamburger
(36)
Lasagne
(1)
Lobster
(27)
Lobster Roll
(20)
Meatloaf
(1)
Omelette
(5)
Oyster
(20)
Pancakes
(7)
Pasta
(1)
Polenta
(2)
Porterhouse Steak
(1)
Ramen
(2)
Ribs
(5)
Salad
(58)
Sandwiches
(2)
Shrimp
(32)
Souvlaki
(1)
Tapas
(1)
Tempura
(1)
Tortillas
(2)
More
Dietary Restrictions
Meals
(25)
(91)
(92)
Price
Cheap Eats
(35)
Mid-range
(142)
Fine Dining
(15)
Restaurant features
Accepts Credit Cards
(18)
Free Wifi
(22)
Parking Available
(32)
Reservations
(45)
Serves Alcohol
(63)
Takeout
(75)
Television
(21)
Wheelchair Accessible
(70)
More
Good for
Bar Scene
(23)
(18)
Kids
(45)
Local cuisine
(18)
(8)
More
Pizza (9)
Seafood (33)
Italian (18)
Mexican (8)
Deli (7)
Cafe (8)
American (66)
Bar (24)
Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market
$$ - $$$, American, Seafood
Greenport 5.3 km away
Lucharito's
$$ - $$$, Mexican, Southwestern, Latin
Greenport 5.3 km away
Southold Fish Market
$$ - $$$, American, Seafood
Southold 6.2 km away
Salt
$$ - $$$, American, Bar, Seafood
Shelter Island
18 Bay
$$$$
Shelter Island
Vine Street Cafe
$$$$, American
Shelter Island
The Frisky Oyster
$$$$, American, Seafood, International
Greenport 5.3 km away
Rams Head Inn Restaurant
$$$$, American
Shelter Island
Southold Fish Market
$$ - $$$, American, Seafood
Southold 6.2 km away
Salamander's On Front
$$ - $$$, American
Greenport 5.4 km away
Noah's
$$ - $$$, American, Seafood
Greenport 5.4 km away
American Beech
$$ - $$$, Seafood, American
Greenport 5.5 km away
Caci Restaurants
$$ - $$$, American, Grill, Italian
Shelter Island
Find a table
Page at 63 Main
$$ - $$$, American
Sag Harbor 7.3 km away
Find a table
Andy's
$$ - $$$, American
Greenport 5.4 km away
Find a table
Olive Branch Restaurant & Cafe
$$ - $$$, Mediterranean, Turkish
Greenport 5.4 km away
Find a table
Sterlington Deli
$, American, Deli
Greenport 5.4 km away
Stars Cafe
$, American, Cafe
Shelter Island
Marie Eiffel Market
$$ - $$$, American, Cafe, Deli
Shelter Island
The Islander
$, American, Diner
Shelter Island
Commander Cody's
$, American, Seafood
Shelter Island
Erik's Breakfast & Lunch
$, American, Cafe
Southold 9.4 km away
Bella Vita Pizza
$, Italian, Pizza
Shelter Island
Sort by:
  • Ranking
  • Name
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results in neighbouring cities.
Limit search to Shelter Island.
#1 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Reserve
#2 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Reserve
Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#1 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
Sterlington Deli Greenport, NY 5.4 km away
#2 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
Lucharito's Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#3 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
Marie Eiffel Market Shelter Island Heights
#1 of 1 Bakeries in Shelter Island
The Frisky Oyster Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#4 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
Southold Fish Market Southold, NY 6.2 km away
#2 of 28 Restaurants in Southold
#3 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
#4 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Mexican
Salamander's On Front Greenport, NY 5.4 km away
#5 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
#2 of 2 Coffee & Tea in Shelter Island
#5 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ American Grill Italian Seafood
Reserve
Noah's Greenport, NY 5.4 km away
#6 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
Reserve
Rams Head Inn Restaurant Shelter Island Heights
#6 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$$$ American
North Fork Table Southold, NY 7.8 km away
#1 of 28 Restaurants in Southold
Reserve
PORT Waterfront Bar and Grill Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#8 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
1943 Pizza Bar Greenport, NY 5.5 km away
#7 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
#8 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$ American Diner
American Beech Greenport, NY 5.5 km away
#9 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ Seafood American
Reserve
The American Hotel Sag Harbor 7.3 km away
#1 of 40 Restaurants in Sag Harbor
Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy Shelter Island Heights
#9 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$ Cafe Diner
#10 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
$$ - $$$ Seafood American
Sunset Beach Shelter Island Heights
#11 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Agave grill and cantina Greenport, NY 5.4 km away
#10 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
The Flying Goat Restaurant Shelter Island Heights
#12 of 21 Restaurants in Shelter Island
Crazy Beans Greenport Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#12 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
Hellenic Snack Bar & Restaurant East Marion, NY 6.8 km away
#1 of 3 Restaurants in East Marion
Claudio's Restaurant Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#13 of 46 Restaurants in Greenport
$$ - $$$ American Bar Seafood Soups