We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows:
Internet Explorer
,
Mozilla Firefox
,
Google Chrome
. Mac:
Safari
.
Herkimer
Herkimer Tourism
Herkimer Accommodation
Herkimer Bed and Breakfast
Herkimer Holiday Rentals
Herkimer Holiday Packages
Herkimer Flights
Herkimer Restaurants
Herkimer Attractions
Herkimer Travel Forum
Herkimer Photos
Herkimer Map
Herkimer Guide
All Herkimer Hotels
Herkimer Hotel Deals
Popular Herkimer Categories
Herkimer Pet Friendly Motels
Herkimer Pet Friendly Campsites
Family Hotels Herkimer
Near Landmarks
Hotels near Herkimer Diamond Mines
Hotels near Ace Of Diamonds Mine
Hotels near Herkimer County Historical Society
All Herkimer Restaurants
Popular Types of Food
Chinese Restaurants in Herkimer
Delis in Herkimer
Fast Food Restaurants in Herkimer
Gluten Free Restaurants in Herkimer
Irish Restaurants in Herkimer
Italian Restaurants for Families in Herkimer
Italian Restaurants in Herkimer
Pizza for Families in Herkimer
Pizza for Lunch in Herkimer
Pizza in Herkimer
Seafood Restaurants in Herkimer
Vegan Restaurants in Herkimer
Vegetarian Restaurants in Herkimer
Popular Dishes
Best Hamburgers in Herkimer
Best Shrimp in Herkimer
Best Corned Beef in Herkimer
Best Cupcake in Herkimer
Best French Toast in Herkimer
Best Meatloaf in Herkimer
Best Omelettes in Herkimer
Best Ice Cream in Herkimer
Popular Restaurant Categories
Dinner Restaurants in Herkimer
Bakeries in Herkimer
Coffee & Tea in Herkimer
Desserts in Herkimer
Near Hotels
Restaurants near Red Roof Inn & Suites Herkimer
Restaurants near Inn Towne Motel
Restaurants near Glen Ridge Motel
Restaurants near Budget Inn Motel
Near Landmarks
Restaurants near Herkimer Diamond Mines
Restaurants near Ace Of Diamonds Mine
Herkimer
Trips
Tip:
All of your saved places can be found here in My Trips.
Inbox
Inbox
See all
Log in
to get trip updates and message other travellers.
Profile
Join
Search
Enter a destination
Search
Travel feed: Herkimer
Hotels
Things to do
Restaurants
Flights
Holiday Rentals
Rental Cars
Travel Forum
Airlines
Best of 2019
Help Centre
Log in
Join
Recently viewed
Bookings
Inbox
More
Help Centre
Best Restaurants in Herkimer, NY
United States
New York (NY)
Herkimer
Herkimer Restaurants
Restaurants in Herkimer
View map
Also show
Hotels
Things to Do
Also show
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Return to Map
Establishment Type
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Dessert
Coffee & Tea
Bakeries
Bars & Pubs
More
Less
Cuisines & Dishes
American
(16)
Italian
(10)
Pizza
(10)
Asian
(1)
Bar
(7)
Brew Pub
(1)
Chinese
(3)
Deli
(1)
Diner
(1)
Fast food
(1)
French
(1)
Gastropub
(1)
German
(1)
Irish
(1)
Japanese
(1)
Middle Eastern
(1)
Pub
(7)
Seafood
(2)
Soups
(1)
Sushi
(1)
Corned Beef
(1)
Cupcake
(1)
Fish & Chips
(1)
French Toast
(1)
Hamburger
(7)
Ice Cream
(2)
Lobster
(1)
Meatloaf
(1)
Omelette
(1)
Pancakes
(2)
Poutine
(1)
Salad
(8)
Sandwiches
(2)
Shrimp
(3)
Tacos
(1)
Tempura
(1)
Wings
(3)
More
Cuisine
Dishes
Sorry—we couldn't find
{0}
Select None
Apply
Dietary Restrictions
Vegetarian Friendly
(6)
Gluten Free Options
(3)
Vegan Options
(1)
Meals
Breakfast
(8)
Brunch
(3)
Lunch
(33)
Dinner
(33)
Price
Cheap Eats
(11)
Mid-range
(36)
Fine Dining
(1)
Restaurant features
Parking Available
(4)
Reservations
(10)
Serves Alcohol
(10)
Takeout
(17)
Television
(5)
Wheelchair Accessible
(12)
More
Restaurant features
Select None
Apply
Good for
Bar Scene
(5)
Child-friendly
(18)
Groups
(3)
Kids
(10)
Romantic
(1)
More
Good for
Select None
Apply
Browse Herkimer by Food
See all
Pizza
(6)
Italian
(5)
American
(10)
Bar
(6)
Moderately Priced
See all
Crazy Otto's Empire Diner
282 Reviews
$$ - $$$, American, Diner
P K's Pub
84 Reviews
$$ - $$$, American, Bar, Pub
Waterfront Grille
221 Reviews
$$ - $$$, American, Bar
Jamo's
43 Reviews
$$ - $$$, American, Bar, Pub
Lunch
See all
Tony's Deli and Pizza
28 Reviews
$, Pizza, Italian
Yetty's Pizza & Pasta
50 Reviews
$$ - $$$, Italian, Pizza
Dominick's Deli
12 Reviews
Soups, Deli
Denny's
104 Reviews
$, American
Cheap Eats
See all
Fat Cats Herkimer
17 Reviews
$, Seafood
Tony's Deli and Pizza
28 Reviews
$, Pizza, Italian
Denny's
104 Reviews
$, American
Borunda Chinese Buffet
7 Reviews
$, Chinese
Sort by:
Ranking
Name
You are zoomed out too far to see location pins. Please zoom back in.
Willing to travel? We found great results outside Herkimer.
Expand your search.
Willing to travel? We found great results outside Herkimer.
Expand your search.
Crazy Otto's Empire Diner
282 reviews
#1 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Diner
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Gluten Free Options
“
A vacation from your busy day
”
16/02/2019
“
Unbelievable Cheeseburger
”
06/02/2019
Heidelberg Bakery Store
72 reviews
#1 of 2 Dessert in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
German
Vegetarian Friendly
“
MUST VISIT! GREAT FOOD
”
28/01/2019
“
Simple Meals, excellent breads
”
29/10/2018
P K's Pub
84 reviews
#2 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Bar
Pub
“
Amazing Food
”
01/02/2019
“
Best meal in Herkimer
”
12/11/2018
Waterfront Grille
221 reviews
#3 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
“
Nice lunch, good view of the Erie Canal
”
14/10/2018
“
Nice lunch
”
14/10/2018
Pk's tavern
28 reviews
#4 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Bar
Brew Pub
Pub
“
Great venue for a party
”
26/11/2018
“
Consistently Great Food
”
14/01/2018
Tony's Deli and Pizza
28 reviews
#5 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$
Pizza
Italian
“
Good and Quick Service
”
19/06/2018
“
Lightly crispy-bottomed disc of joy!
”
23/01/2018
Fat Cats Herkimer
17 reviews
#6 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$
Seafood
“
Awesome place to eat
”
31/08/2018
“
Good Food, Good Price
”
28/05/2018
Denny's
104 reviews
#7 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$
American
Vegetarian Friendly
“
Only place open New Year's Day for breakfa...
”
08/01/2019
“
It's Denny's
”
15/10/2018
Jamo's
43 reviews
#8 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Bar
Pub
Vegetarian Friendly
“
Herkimer taco & fish & chips
”
05/08/2018
“
Good food, nice price
”
11/07/2018
Vinny's Pizzeria & Restaurant
23 reviews
#9 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
Italian
Pizza
“
Huge portions, great food, decent staff, s...
”
25/07/2018
“
Bring an appetite !
”
20/04/2018
Tokyo Sushi Restaurant
28 reviews
#10 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
Japanese
Sushi
Asian
“
Three roll combo :)
”
11/06/2018
“
Don't use the bathrooms!!!!!!
”
08/01/2019
Salvatore Herkimer
11 reviews
#11 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
Italian
Pizza
“
homemade soups, garlic knots, pizza slices...
”
28/08/2018
“
Great place, huge portions!
”
24/07/2018
Fat Cat's Fish Fry
14 reviews
#12 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
Seafood
“
Unbelievable Fish Fry
”
06/02/2019
“
friday night fish fry
”
29/01/2019
Applebee's
51 reviews
#13 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Bar
Pub
“
Average
”
03/09/2018
“
Average for Applebees
”
07/08/2018
Yetty's Pizza & Pasta
50 reviews
#14 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
Italian
Pizza
“
No eggplant
”
09/08/2018
“
Very Good Food
”
29/05/2018
Miners Table
21 reviews
#15 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$$ - $$$
American
Pizza
Italian
Bar
Pub
“
Welcoming atmosphere
”
18/08/2018
“
Order the pizza!
”
20/01/2019
Woody's Ice Cream Place
11 reviews
#2 of 2 Dessert in Herkimer
“
Great Ice Cream
”
31/07/2018
“
Very creamy!
”
02/07/2018
Dominick's Deli
12 reviews
#16 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
Soups
Deli
“
Great for Lunch
”
11/11/2017
“
Amazing
”
17/06/2017
Borunda Chinese Buffet
7 reviews
#17 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
$
Chinese
“
Most excellent!
”
19/10/2018
“
Lots of variety
”
03/10/2018
New Foo Chow
5 reviews
#18 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
Great SOUP
”
23/05/2017
“
Only have had takeout
”
13/03/2016
Carney's Corners
4 reviews
#19 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
Ordered Delivered
”
23/05/2017
“
Great Subs & Service
”
14/08/2014
Order Online
Asteroga Ale House
5 reviews
#20 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
Neighborhood feel
”
28/08/2018
“
Best Wings
”
06/02/2019
The Endzone Pub and Grub
3 reviews
#21 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
Cold beer and good wings
”
06/02/2019
“
a nice place for a few beers and decent fo...
”
28/04/2017
Arby's
5 reviews
#22 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
American
“
Great food
”
19/09/2018
“
No roast beef
”
25/08/2017
Salty Shamrock
2 reviews
#23 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
Irish
Pub
“
Great place!
”
24/04/2017
“
Great Hidden Irish Pub
”
30/04/2015
Dunkin' Donuts
3 reviews
#1 of 2 Coffee & Tea in Herkimer
“
Extremely busy but Service Affected
”
20/08/2017
“
quick stop for coffee on our way to Cooper...
”
26/08/2016
McDonald's
6 reviews
#24 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
Typical McDonalds breakfast
”
28/08/2018
“
frys and drinks
”
01/01/2018
Burger King
8 reviews
#25 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
great burgers
”
31/08/2018
“
No service
”
23/05/2018
Greek Gyros
5 reviews
#26 of 33 Restaurants in Herkimer
“
Can’t get more authentic
”
26/11/2018
“
Love the gyro platter
”
01/10/2018
Dunkin' Donuts
5 reviews
#2 of 2 Coffee & Tea in Herkimer
“
great donuts
”
03/09/2018
“
bkfast quick stop
”
01/01/2018
Previous
Next
1
2