We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
The latest reviews. The lowest prices. The perfect place to shop for hotels.

Italian Restaurants in Fire Island

View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Your SelectionsClear all
(23)
Cuisines & Dishes
(37)
(23)
(6)
Bar
(29)
(4)
Diner
(3)
(4)
Grill
(1)
(2)
(2)
(14)
Pub
(17)
(4)
Southwestern
(2)
(6)
Burrito
(2)
Cheesecake
(1)
Crab
(4)
Filet Mignon
(4)
Hamburger
(1)
Lobster
(7)
Oyster
(2)
Paella
(2)
Pasta
(1)
Ribs
(1)
Shrimp
(10)
More
Dietary Restrictions
Gluten Free Options
(10)
Vegetarian Friendly
(2)
Vegan Options
(1)
Meals
Price
Cheap Eats
(20)
Mid-range
(164)
Fine Dining
(8)
Restaurant features
Free Wifi
(5)
Parking Available
(19)
Reservations
(45)
Serves Alcohol
(59)
Takeout
(47)
Wheelchair Accessible
(52)
More
Good for
Bar Scene
(26)
Business meetings
(13)
(28)
Kids
(22)
Local cuisine
(1)
More
Sort by:
  • Relevance
  • Ranking
  • Name
We found great results, but some are outside Fire Island. Showing results within 40 km of Fire Island.
Limit search to Fire Island.

Michael's Ristorante & Pizzeria Ocean Beach

#1 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza Seafood Healthy

Cherry Grove Pizza Cherry Grove

#2 of 23 Results
$ Italian Pizza

The Pines Bistro and Martini Bar Fire Island Pines

#3 of 23 Results
$$$$ Italian

Vinnie's Mulberry Street East Islip 9.6 km away

#4 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Pizza Italian

Da Noi Italian Restaurant Islip 10.3 km away

#5 of 23 Results
$$$$ Italian

Verace Islip 10.2 km away

#6 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian
Reserve

Butera's Sayville 11.6 km away

#7 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian
Reserve

Francesco's Trattoria East Islip 9.6 km away

#8 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza

La Tavola Sayville 11.3 km away

#9 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian
Reserve

Mannino's Oakdale 10.8 km away

#10 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian

A S Italian Fine Foods East Islip 9.7 km away

#11 of 23 Results
Italian Seafood

Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta East Islip 9.6 km away

#12 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza

Vinnies Mulberry Street East Islip 9.6 km away

#13 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza

Original Mama's Oakdale 10.1 km away

#14 of 23 Results
Italian Pizza Seafood

Sal's Pizza Sayville 11.3 km away

#15 of 23 Results

Gio's Pizzeria East Islip 10.6 km away

#16 of 23 Results
$ Italian Pizza

Mama's Italian Restaurant Oakdale 10.7 km away

#17 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian

Angela's Pizzeria Islip 10.7 km away

#18 of 23 Results
Italian Pizza

Ralphs Italian Ices Bay Shore 11.2 km away

#19 of 23 Results
$ Italian

Tina's II Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria Bay Shore 10.7 km away

#20 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza

The Pie at Salvatores Bay Shore 11.1 km away

#21 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza

Frank and Maria's Italian Pork Store Bay Shore 11.1 km away

#22 of 23 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian

Fratelli Pizzeria Bay Shore 10.8 km away

#23 of 23 Results
$ Italian Pizza