Very good food all around. Price is reasonable. Buffalo chicken pizza with blue cheese is great. It's not like traditional buffalo chicken pizza. It's very sweet, much like South End II in AC.
1 - 10 of 55 reviews
We ordered 1) stuffed shells, $10.99. 2). Pasta With mussels, $14.99; Both include soup or salad. We chose soup, with good quality & quantity. Both dishes come with white or red sauces. We chose home made Marinara sauce. Both dishes were delicious.
My daughter and I have been going here ever Saturday for ever. Then I got my father hooked and he really won't go anywhere else .( I have a really big family out of about 12of us, only one isn't a big fan) The service...More
I was very disappointed. I was always a fan. Not sure what happened? Our pizza was so greasy. Buffalo tails were smaller. They pound the chicken out not like before when it was big healthy chunks of buffalo tails. Sorry won't be back
By far hands down the best buffalo tails, wings and pizza! Quaint setting on the lake! Eat in or take out!
If you want delicious Italian food, steak sandwiches stuffed with meat to overflowing, friendly service and excellent prices, Costello's in Historic Smithville, N.J. is the place for you. We were really surprised by the amount of food we got. We ordered steak sandwiches, fries and...More
Always see a full parking lot so decided to try Costello's. Menu was fine but the service and the quality were lacking.. Maybe it was just an off day. Will give them a second try, I'm sure..
This may be a bit out of the way and tucked in along the highway but this restaurant serves some of the finest Italian homemade food.
After a day of sightseeing we decided to try Costello's for takeout. It was literally a few steps away from our room at the Smithville Inn. Our order consisted of 3 items: 1 Caesar salad, 1 Eggplant Parm sandwich and ! order of Pasta Fagiole....More