I've read about this place previously and I was gifted their book last year so I had to visit. The pies are really tasty but a tad sweet for someone used to more moderate levels of sweetness. The staff was okay the day I visited.
1 - 10 of 41 reviews
During our recent visit, went to the Brooklyn library location to get the pies. They were out of the salted caramel apple pies!! Had the honey and it was delish!! Went to the pie counter in Dean Street. Very quaint. Very cute. The staff was...More
We've been going to Four & Twenty for years, and we love the pies at the 3rd Ave location. We were in lower Manhattan today, and went to a cafe JUST to have Four & Twenty's pie. We brought friends who'd never been before and...More
The pats are wonderful with crust as good as I ever had anywhere. There are a wide variety of types but go with the special flavor. , you will love it. I find that taking out is a better choice than waiting for service which...More
Heavenly pies. The chocolate chess and sweet honey in particular. Really sad they didn't have their famous pecan but oh my lord I would go back to Brooklyn just to stop in and grab a few slices of their pies.
Walked here from Times Square (made a few other stops too) and had the salted caramel apple pie. Tasted so good with the whipped cream, and I usually hate whipped cream. I thoroughly recommend this place if you're a pie fan or have their cookbook...More
The pies are creative and fresh. Worth the trip. Some of the best pies I have eaten. Tried Rhubard Crumble, Matcha, Lemon Chess, Nectarine Blackberry....
Really fantastic spot for pie. Fresh, seasonal ingredients. Service is a little snarky but pie is so incredible you don't even care.
If you are in the area I would recommend stopping at the Brooklyn Public Library location and try a slice or two or four of their pies. We tried the Salted Caramel Apple, Lemon Chess, Black Bottom Oat, and Salty Honey. I think the overwhelming...More