First time having there pizza it was amazing and you get 2 slices and a drink for 4 dollars you can't beat it
I have had pizza from all over the world, Italy included and Tony's pizza is still my favorite. I just spent 3 days in Rome, NY and I ate Tony's twice!
I'm not Italian and I'm not particularly fond of Italian cuisine. But Tony's Pizzeria is pretty darn good. I've had pizza in Italy, Tony's pizza is much, much better. Their steak sandwich is awesome. The place isn't much to look at, but food is good....More
I love pizza from Tony's on Jay. Its the best pizza in CNY. I wish they would expand their menu. The garlic pizza is to die for!
Whenever I travel home to Rome, we ALWAYS have Tony's on Jay! Hands down, THE best! Each time, perfect crust, perfect size, perfect amount of cheese! Was there this month for a week...and what did we eat everyday? Tony's on Jay! Then home to diet...More
I prefer thin crust pizza but I do come here for their subs. Just personal preference, a lot of people I know swear by their pizza.
A Rome tradition. I stop in at least once a week for lunch. Food quality and flavor is consistent and of good value.