Lovely restaurant, professional staff and delicious food. We were there on a Monday, happy hour all evening, reduced priced drinks and $1 oysters! There is a garden patio in the rear.
1 - 10 of 178 reviews
Wonderful sea food restaurant on the West Side of Manhattan, great ambience, wonderful staff and delicious food. Can’t wait to visit New York again to go back!
Great find, we booked online but arrived early and the restaurant were able to find us a table, there is a daily selection of local oysters available which were superb if on the small side. The lobster roll as a main comes with a heap...More
We were looking for a place that offered great food, of course, at a reasonable price to celebrate a good friend's birthday . Our original choice cancelled our dinner reservation for 7 because of a broken pipe. (Who can make this stuff up?) A friend...More
We came here based on a recommendation as my husband is a big fish/seafood fan. We really liked the menu and making a choice was easy. Both our starters and mains were delicious, good portions and well presented. We were sat outside and tables were...More
Food was tasty, presented beautifully. The pacific oysters were our favs! Enjoyed everything from fish tacos to the hangar steak! The fish special was cooked to perfection. Mini-dessert pudding was yummy ! Staff was amazing; they anticipated our needs! Will be going back! They held...More
went to the Mermaid Inn East Village with two friends and enjoyed the experience - the staff are friendly and attentive, the food is nice, the place is cozy - all in all recommended. their menu is mainly fish-based but has meat and veggie options,...More
Thanks for dining with us in the East Village! We're happy to hear that you had a wonderful time and appreciate the recommendation.
We have frequented the Mermaid in the UWS on numerous occasions and loved it. Decided on this trip to experience the east side version. First and foremost, staff was incredible. Amazingly attentive and responsive. Secondly, food was FANTASTIC. We are huge seafood fans and did...More
I researched seafood restaurants in NY, looking for new places for our trip. Lobster roll was on my agenda, and this place got great ratings. The dining room at the back is nice, we had a table for four. My cocktail was so spicy I...More
Hi Barbara, Thank you for dining with us! I'm sorry to hear that the lobster roll did not live up to expectations -- we're always trying to make our food and experience the best that they can be, so feedback is always appreciated.
$1 oysters!!! What more do I have to say? The food is great. And after the meal you get a little complimentary chocolate pudding! I just wish they'd put the shrimp cocktail bloody mary back on the menu.
Thanks for the lovely review, Marielle!