We happened upon this quaint place as we walked through NYC. It is so charming, and the cookies are so delicious! We purchase several sugar cookies for our trip home and we are already wishing we had more.
1 - 10 of 465 reviews
Stopped here for a snack while visiting NYC. I had seen pictures on trip advisor about the s'mores cookies on Trip Advisor and wanted to try one, sadly they didn't have one so I opted for chocolate chip. They do have a daily menu in...More
These are some of my favorite cookies. If you like iced cookies, go for the Cookies and Cream or Red Velvet. If your preference is real cookies, go for one of the chocolate chip cookie versions. I also love it that they sell a choice...More
I went here and waited in line because they say they have gluten free options! No they don't. My daughter loved here chocolate chip cookie though. It had big chunks of chocolate instead of small chips. Just don't expect gluten free anything.
I have been in this cookie store several times in the past but the last visit I did I was surprised to see a long line. I usually get a regular chocolate chip cookie which I find decent and nothing spectacular but there more selections...More
We were looking for a coffee shop to kill some time and get out of the rain, and I was very happy to find Schmackary's! The cookie I had was amazing! (cereal killer) and unlike so many coffee shops, there was a lot of choices...More
I discovered this place after craving something sweet after watching a Broadway play. I braved the line in the cold. It must be good for people to wait in the cold for this. As I got closer my heart beating with excitement on the perfect...More
Celiac friendly, gluten free bakeries are not easy to find, but this one is a find. We only tried three different cookies plus the macaroons, but everything is fresh and easy. Small, but very good. Will visit often.
After the solid reviews on Yelp decided to see what all the rage was about this place. Well it did not disappoint at all. Ordered 6 various cookies more than enough for 6 to 8 people. My favorite by far was the maple bacon with...More