I work close and go hear when ever I'm able. There sandwiches are trucker huge, so be hungry!! Soooo goooood!!!
1 - 10 of 28 reviews
Currently, this is the only place on Shelter Island that's open early in the morning and where you can buy a cup of coffee. They offer a tempting case of breakfast sweets and the short order cook makes sandwiches to order at this deli. But...More
I ordered the grilled cheese with bacon. My daughter had the turkey with avocado. We both had special requests because of food allergies and they got the orders right the first time. The sandwiches were great. The view of the hill and marina were a...More
We stopped here for breakfast and also took sandwiches for lunch while enjoying the zoo. Breakfast sandwiches on English muffins and breakfast burrito were all very tasty and substantial. Lunch sandwiches were huge and delicious. They do not skimp on the meat. We also tried...More
I have gone here a couple times, but they tend to close whenever they want to. During my last two visits to the area, they were closed before 1:30.
Stumbled on this fantastic wee cafe/deli the best barbeque beef sandwich on Shelter Island, prices are really cheap, my wife and I stopped here every day for coffee and a sandwich, we just loved this place
We ordered 2 sandwiches to go and they were huge. Very, very good!! It may look like a hole in the wall kind of place but, we enjoyed those sandwiches more than anywhere we ate in San Diego. We just happened to walk by it...More
Stayed on Shelter Island for three days and went to Pearsons Deli every day. Lovely freshly made sandwiches, staff very understanding of our picky requests !! Sat out the back on the patio to eat lunch with a nice cold beer, looking out at the...More
This was recommended by a friend, so close to Humphrey's. Awesome sandwiches! Breakfast Burrito (egg and cheese) was great. The tortilla was so fresh!