Carried out 2 large pizzas- 1 specialty BLT & 1 just pepperoni for$32. Very good pizza. Have always had good experience & food here!
1 - 10 of 77 reviews
Although this place has been around since 1953, we only discovered it 4 years ago. It immediately became one of our favorites, and is one of our must-have meals in Sheboygan. It's a tiny place,so it's best to go during non-peak hours. The pizza is...More
Have their pizza and chicken delivered all the time. Great pizza for the price. Chicken dinner awesome. Just about the only pizza hubby will order. Small restaurant and parking, but so worth it.
Ordered a delivery pizza on a Sunday night. Totally well prepared generous toppings ..prompt and hot arrival. So pleased.
We had a pizza delivered to our hotel. It was there promptly and was very tasty. Make sure to ask for plates and utensils and napkins.
Faye's is a bit of a dive when you walk in - not pretty for the eyes - but that's OK because the food is amazing! There are cheaper options in Sheboygan, there are fancier options. But if you're looking for a great value pizza...More
Nothing fancy but the service is good and the pizza is great. Great toppings and great thin crispy crust. Side salad will feed 2 people. Good service.
I hadn't had a really tasty thin pizza crust for a long time, so Faye's crust was a treat. It was crisp and flavorful. The toppings on the house deluxe pizza that we ordered were plentiful. The sauce is the mild kind of pizza sauce...More