When we first moved to Cedarburg, people kept asking if we had been to The Farmstead. Finally I went there with a coworker for lunch - it was ok. Then my husband and I went on a weekday evening. The food was just OK and...More
1 - 10 of 231 reviews
It took us awhile to find the Farmstead but it was good. They are hidden in an old home behind a strip mall and a stand of cedars. The inside is very cozy, about 10 tables and a couple booths plus a bar area. The...More
Long-ish wait for a table, but the bartenders took good care of us. Wait staff and hostess were also very attentive once we got seated. We both enjoyed our dinners and agree that the garlic glaze is delicious. The open dining room was very fun.
Four of us went for lunch on a Wednesday. Two had cod, one blue gill, and one had the chicken avocado sandwich. The cod was over done but okay. Blue gill was good. Coleslaw had no flavor. BUT my Sandwich was delicious. Nothing to write...More
Beautiful 1800's stone structure interior, wonderful experience , steaks are tender, wonderful optional seasoning, garlic glaze is amazing, you must try the seven layer salad, it to die for. Farm bites as appetizers are little tenderloin on garlic toast with a homemade pickle. Great drinks,...More
Farmstead is known for their steaks, but I had the Walleye dinner which was great. Unfortunately we waited way too long to get seated (over an hour). Once seated, the service was good and we enjoyed the ambience. It was a cool little place.
Went here with my husband and my twin sister and her husband for their 20th anniversary and had a wonderful time!!! Beautiful place with a great warm cozy atmosphere!! Service at the bar and table was excellent. We had the pickle tenderloin appetizer and it...More
Geez, reading other reviews, I have to question if they've tried other places. 5 O'Clock, Joey Gerards, are MUCH better. OK, Farmstead is good. Nice place, good food, but definitely NOT worth the waits they always have. Had Top steak. Prepared as ordered, but waitress...More
We have come here multiple times and just love the food, service and atmosphere!! Was a little disappointed to find this trip that the bartender we loved had gone somewhere else!!!! All in all hands down the best restaurant in Cedarburg!