Been going to Tony's for over 40 years.... Never been disappointed with meal or service.. Tony's has and will always have the best pizza. Check it out for yourself.
1 - 10 of 106 reviews
Place is unique but pizza is disappointing - very bready and not much sauce. Perhaps the rest of the Italian menu is good. They serve garlic bread upon sitting down that is delicious. Nice seating area overlooking the water which makes for a relaxing drink...More
Three of us went and we like it. first guy Philly cheese steak, 2nd guy Lasagna, me spaghetti. All good, except spaghetti noodles were overcooked a little. Great salad, minestroni, and tira misu. No complaints. Outstanding service, clean, and friendly.
The people cannot be friendlier, cute place but the spaghetti sauce was awful. It tasted like hickory smoke flavor. Had a roasted garlic which was delicious and the bread was phenomenal. The ravioli had hardly any meat in it and unfortunately with the sauce it...More
We stopped in after an afternoon of hiking. We selected a table with a view of Oyster Bay, enjoyed a chicken pesto pizza and beers. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. The owner was friendly and explained the many photos hanging all over the restaurant....More
I'm spoiled with new york pizza so their pizza obviously didn't compare the crust was not good. And the meat sauce was horrifyingly black on the pasta. Friendly staff, cool place, but not very good food
Like most folks who were born and raise in the area, Tony's has and will always been the Italian restaurant to go to... Never disappointed, you'll leave feeling full, content and looking forward to your return..besides the great food, the staff/ ownership go above and...More
Tonys has been in my community since I was a kid. I'm 51 now and still enjoy going there. The food is amazing and they offer all the traditional Italian fair. The pizza is great too! Always look forward to going to Tonys!
While interior is dated, much of it is years of sentimental photos of happy customers for one occasion or another. Definitely the definition of that one small town restaurant people reminisce about! That said, the pizza here is worthy of praise, and 'The Works' (minus...More
Truly authentic Italian food... the best around in my opinion! Everything is good there! The pizza is amazing and so well topped. We have never been disappointed.