Fresh everything! Best pizza and any other Pie you would like. Mainly takeout but there are a few outside picnic tables. Nothing fancy because all the focus is on PIES. Chicken Pot Pie will make everyone happy.
1 - 10 of 168 reviews
The food here does not disappoint! My wife had a Dagwood sandwich which she says is probably the best sandwich she has ever had. I had a single-sized Smithfield pot pie, which was delicious. We did sample a piece of pie, but the entrees are...More
I've been friends with the owner and workers for a while now, stopping by for meals. They're friendly folks in a little shop on the corner near a 7-11. Food is great, slightly more expensive than subway or papa johns, but MUCH better. I'll be...More
My son and I stopped, thinking it would have fried pies. It didn't but it did have whole pies or slices that you could buy - unsure if they were good, we settled on a piece of key lime pie and it was good but...More
Big, delicious pies or slices ~ from fruits to creams and/or nuts; from pot pies to pizza pies, this tiny place has it! We drove 30 miles out of our way when we were near the area just to go back. The portions are generous,...More
My family and I always made sure our trip to Williamsburg included a visit to the Jamestown Pie Co. Two years ago, we were disappointed with the pizza we ordered there. This year, we skipped the pizza but bought a fruit pie that cost $22....More