The "Fat Baby" pizza and the "Big Mick" sub were both very good, and both had a good amount of cheese.
1 - 10 of 845 reviews
The best Pizza I have found on the Island! Excellent food, great atmosphere and wonderful and helpful wait staff. Desserts are just as good as well.
Last January was my third visit to Fat Baby's; a dining experience I always enjoy. As before, I ordered the Big Mick sausage/meatball combination sandwich. This is one of the best in the South! The staff is friendly and helpful, and the sandwich was prepared...More
As locals, this is the only place that comes to mind as far as pizza is concerned. Little known secret. Don't go there just for pizza.. They serve the best cheeseburger on the island. OMG and the Vermonter(ham and cheese). Oh, and check out the...More
Great spot for just a slice or two. Wonderful not to have to buy the entire pie. Super New York Style Pizza. I know being born and raised in Brooklyn.
Great place for kids and families. The pizza looked amazing but I couldn’t enjoy it with my gluten allergy. :( No gluten free options other than salad.More
Dear IslanderKDM, Thanks for stopping into Fat Baby's Pizza and Subs and for taking the time to write a review. Although we do have a few items other than salads that are gluten-free, you are right, our selection is limited. The reason for that is...More
First time at Fat Baby's included a greek salad as well as a spinach salad. Both very fresh and tasted excellent. We ordered a Fat Baby pizza, and were very pleased. It was fantastic! Also, took home 2 of the individual cheesecakes for later -...More
We were interested in a lite meal, and were pointed towards this restaurant. We shared a sub, and it was delicious. It isn’t often that we can find a good Italian Sub outside of New York, but we did. It was excellent. Service was quick,...More
Woot Woot! Thanks, Duffer. Glad we were able to accommodate. Hope to see y'all again next trip. Pete Bernstein Owner Fat Baby's Pizza and Subs
Hungry for a great calzone? Then you really need to give Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs a try. This was our first visit and we were astounded by the size of our Calzones. I had the full meat while my wife had “the works” for...More