Crowded and overrated. Food had too much breading on the shrimp and oysters and too crunchy. Kind of bland taste. Nothing special about the service or food.
Is this restaurant good for lunch?
Is this restaurant good for dinner?
Is this restaurant good for breakfast?
Is this primarily a coffee shop?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
Reilleys is the place to be on HH any Monday evening with its Maine Lobster special. Have done it several times and always a treat eating a lobster dinner for the cost of the lobster at a food store.
As is our tradition, we made a reservation to have the Monday night Lobster special at Reilleys almost as soon as we hit the island. Normally we stay on the opposite end of the island, and we love the Reilleys North End, but we were closer to the Grill and Bar this trip and so that is where we went.... More
We were drawn by all the festive lighting and people at their outdoor bar. Sat outside under heat lamp. Server was great, good recommendations and very attentive. My grilled salmon was cooked perfectly, larger cut than expected, and yummy! My husband had Blue Cheese wedge salad and salmon and loved it. I would have given a 5, but my mashed... More
Went out to catch up with friends and had a great time. Reilley's has a nice pub atmosphere and good food. We went for a drink and appetizer, but with Bridget as our server we stayed for dinner. Her recommendation matched are diet needs, she really listens and it was so nice not to wait for anything. Thank you Bridget.
We had an incredible New Years Eve (fixed menu) with the locals. It was terrific and service was great! It was extremely crowded but we were seated and we had a wonderful meal!
My wife and I went to HHI for my Birthday and New Years. We were told to come to this place for good food and drinks by friends. It greatly surpassed our expectations! Every dish I had was great! We liked the place so much that we came back 3 times during our visit! Great Seafood and drinks! The specials... More
We drove past Reilley's on our way to another restaurant and saw the nearly full parking lot. We decided to stop and we were not disappointed. The food was great, the beer was cold and the atmosphere was enjoyable. Danielle was helpful and recommended the bacon wrapped shrimp. We ordered a trio which had a couple of the shrimp. They... More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing