This was a decent place to stop for lunch. Food and service were average. There is a large gift shop.
1 - 10 of 153 reviews
We have gone there since it first opened. It is not as good as Der Dutchman, etc. In OHIO Amish country but a closer second. Debatable if it is still really Amish but pretty good home cooking anyhow. Der Dutchman is our favorite place anyhow...More
Drove 40 miles for their chicken salad and pies. Arrived at 5:30pm and they were already out of chicken salad. I ordered something else, ham and switch. I took a few bites and lost my appetite. I probably won't return.
I wish I could cook like they do at Mary Yoder's. My meals at home never look as good as they do at Mary Yoder's! When I get near Middlefield, Ohio I usually head for Mary Yoder's because I know I will get great food...More
Checked the GPS for food and came up with this over fast food. The place was pretty busy. The buffet meal is high priced we thought ,and my wife doesn't eat that much any way. Meat loaf dinner from the senior menu was plenty to...More
Met some friends here for lunch. Had the warm buffet and salad bar. The food was delicious and tasty. Service was excellent and friendly.I definitely look forward to returning here again, for more. The desserts are awesome. A great Amish bakery area as well. Take...More
I was expecting more from my food. The BB pie was DELICIOUS. My grilled chicken was a little chewy. My husband Rueben was great. The place was fabulous with so many things to buy, I would go back again
Always have the Turkey, homemade mashies....and stuffing....better than Thanksgiving, cuz I dont have to cook! HUGE portions! I do ask for the Pork gravy, do NOT care for their yellow chicken gravy......homemade rolls with butter or Amish Peanut Butter sauce or homemade Apple Butter...both are...More
I wish I lived in Middlefield! Oh, maybe not, I would weigh 500 lbs! Everything is DELICIOUS! Great value! Great service! And don't forget a raisin filled cookie! Best on the planet!