Surpassed our expectations. Very good food and atmosphere. Meatloaf sounds boring, but theirs is amazing! My wife had the chicken marsala and said that it was the best she’d ever had.
1 - 10 of 826 reviews
My sister's and I ate here while in Maggie Valley. One of them had the Prime Rib and after all of us tasting it we all agreed that this was the juiciest, best tasting, and most tender Prime Rib we had ever put in our...More
What a super review. Thanks so much!!
J. Arthur's never fails to satisfy. It's busy for good reasons. Excellent service and drinks at the bar accompanied by very personable and engaging bartenders. Always stop here while traveling in Maggie Valley. Only open Thursday thru Sunday in the off season (Jan-May).
Our experience was great in every way. The location is beautiful, the atmosphere is warm and friendly, the food was delicious and the staff was helpful.
After waiting almost a 2 hours The prime rib was the worst i have ever had. I ordered rare and it came to me brown. Looked like they cut it off the roast and baked it. It was almost well done. $30. I told them...More
The food is good. The room has been decorated very nicely. This place has a great bar where many locals frequent. The meal for us was okay. We were expecting the food, service and presentation to be as nice as the ambiance and the decorations...More
We live in Waynesville and J Arthur's is our favorite romantic get away. The best Manhattans in western NC. We always sit in the bar area and usually get the same thing. Boring, but I know what I like. I will get prime rib and...More
We have dinned at this restaurant numerous times and are seldom disappointed. The trout is light, flavorful and hard to pass up and guests enjoy the salmon while my husband usually sticks with chicken and pasta. Generally, service is good to very good and the...More
My husband & I came to Maggie Valley, NC this weekend just for an overnight getaway. Immediately when my husband inquired about Prime Rib, the manager of the Five Star Inn said without hesitation, J. Arthur's. He definitely knew what he was talking about. My...More
Thank you so much for your very kind review. Hope you’ll visit us again when you’re in Maggie Valley!