The food was amazing! I would definitely come back. The waitress was amazing. She helped us decide which pizza was perfect for us. The medium was was to big I would suggest the small pizza to share.
1 - 10 of 432 reviews
The pizza crust reminded me of a Domino's do dish pizza and I was truly not impressed with the quality of the picture itself the toppings were very dry the sauce didn't have any taste and quite honestly I was pretty disappointed I had super...More
I LOVE pizza. Even when it's bad pizza it's still pretty good. But the pizza I had yesterday at My Father's Pizza in Black Mountain ranks above the best I've had anywhere, anytime. The crust is perfect--not too thin, perfectly crisp. The marinara sauce and...More
it used to be a good place but now has a cult following. The owner also owns the building where a great bar and restaurant is co-located called the Trailhead but he is so cheap that the wireless in the bar sucks and if you...More
Our lunch here was very good. We were seated immediately on a nice springtime Friday. Prompt and pleasant server. Pizza, frankly, was really not knock-your-socks-off great that I was expecting from reading the TA reviews. Good? Yes! But the sauce was not a standout, the...More
I'm not sure what has changed, but the food at My Father's Pizza has gotten even better in the past year. The bolognese sauce was perfect, and salad was incredibly fresh.
We ordered My Father's Pizza while visiting Old Fort. We got multiple pizzas and cheese bread togo. It was absolutely wonderful. The pizza sauce is amazing!! Very good!! The slices are very small so keep that in mind. 3 large pizzas and 2 breadstick orders...More
Wonderful outdoor seating! Met up with family that included elderly, so park at the upper parking lot and enter through the gate that opens to the outdoor seating to avoid stairs. The bathrooms can be accessed from the same parking lot, so stairs can still...More
Wait was long and bathrooms upstairs made it hard with kids but meal was wonderful. Good salads and wonderful pizza. White garlic cheese was not to be missed!