Food was delicious! We got there early and ordered the pre-fix. I had the scrimp scampi and my husband had mussels. There were enough mussels for 2 meals. Gourmet meal for 29.99 - can't go wrong with that!
1 - 10 of 184 reviews
We went here the other Saturday night for dinner with my brother and sister in law. Dinner was actually very good and every appetizer and entree was both appealing and tasty. Unfortunately, as that it was a Holiday Weekend the prix-fixe was not in effect....More
Visited twice on a recent visit. Hard to avoid their $29 3 course prix-fixe offering. Strong American local menu with a slight lean to local seafood. Dining room is delightful summer or winter-beach cottage-ish. Crispy Calamari salad is a winner-so is the house made bread...More
Great Food with a wonderful atmosphere, our waiter was new but very attentive. Will definitely go back the next time we are in Shelter island
Vine Street Cafe has a great menu and easy, comfortable atmosphere during the offseason. Fresh salad and the calamari as appetizers were a great start. The fresh fish and specials of the day were all excellent. Portion are not large, just enough, and the services...More
Off-season visit to the restaurant. Service was good. Menu was extensive. Pork ribs were outstanding but Ragu Bolognese was too spicey. Very pricey for the entres.
Spent a fabulous and relaxed long weekend on Shelter Island, and a friend said you must dine at Vine. So glad we listened! The place was packed, even though it was "off season". We had a reservation and were promptly seated. The room is warm...More
I was visiting Shelter Island in late September and came here for dinner one night with my brother and one of my best friends. We all loved everything about this place! The country cottage feel, great lighting and simple, rustic yet chic decor. The food...More
We dined there one Saturday evening - the ambiance was cosy and welcoming, the place was packed but we got a table quite soon. Our waiter was attentive and helpful. When the food arrived we were all pleased. I ordered grilled scallops, someone else ordered...More