Pleasant pub atmosphere. Attentive service, fair prices and good food. We had shrimp scampi very garlicky and tasty and a broiled seafood platter with fish, shrimp scallops and baked clams. Warm buttery rolls. What else do you need?
1 - 10 of 434 reviews
We ate here for lunch as we were staying in the Hyatt next door. The owner, Jerry, could not have been more welcoming and hospitable. The interior has an unassuming feel of a local seafood shack, but make no mistake the food here is as...More
Anna, I'm thrilled to hear you had a great experience with us on your recent visit! Thank you for the patronage and thanks for taking the time to review. I'm glad to hear you enjoyed the savory and sweet courses! We hope to have you...More
Jerry & The Mermaid is a very nice restaurant in Riverhead, NY. The seafood selections are plentiful. The Clam Chowder (Manhattan and New England) were outstanding. The linguine with clam sauce was outstanding. When in Riverhead have dinner at Jerry & The Mermaid.More
Louise, Thank you so much for taking the time to review your recent experience. It makes me extremely happy to hear that you had a great experience. We appreciate the patronage and thanks for helping spread the word! Hope to see you back sometime soon....More
Driving through downtown Riverhead which seems to be getting nicer all the time, we spot Jerry & the Mermaid, complete with a sign that offers waterfront dining. Well, that's all in need to see as I love dining waterside & next to a Marina to...More
Paul, Thank you for taking the time to review Jerry's. I'm sorry to hear that you think our restaurant is uninspired, but I'm glad to hear you enjoyed the clams! We are a casual seafood restaurant/clam bar that takes great pride in our local fish/shellfish....More
We tried this Resturant because it was right next to our hotel and offered a nice view of the marina. It seemed a favorite of the locals so our expectations were high. I had the seafood bisque as a starter and it was delicious and...More
Greg, Thank you for dining with us recently at Jerry's. I'm glad you enjoyed the bisque. Our soups are all homemade and we take great pride in our multi generation recipes we use to prepare them. I'm not quite sure how your mussels could have...More
Took two groups here and each person got really fresh fish cooked perfectly. Clams were fresh and shucked cleanly--no bits of shell. Pleasant staff. Nic bar. And Jerry came by each visit and chatted. He cares and it shows.
Jonathon, Thank you for dining with us multiple times. We greatly appreciate the patronage. I'm glad to hear you enjoyed the food and atmosphere. Thanks for taking the time to review. Regards, Jerry Dicecco Chef/Owner: Jerry & The Mermaid
I stayed @Hyatt Place next door, and, because their Seaside Grill closed for the season, on Labor Day (boooo!), I ordered a Blackened Fish (Grouper) Sandwich with waffle fries, The Garlic Chiabatta roll was so flavorful, and was a fabulous compliment to a great piece...More
Sorry you weren't able to visit the Seaside Grill. I'm glad we were able to serve you a Blackened Fish sandwich that you loved! We hope to see you back to the East End sometime soon. Thanks for the patronage and for taking the time...More
we spent the day at the Aquairium the next door for some top of the line food. The servers were friendly and attendtive. The food was very good with not complants. WE meet the owner who came around to every table to see how eveything...More
Richard, Thank for dining with us recently. I'm thrilled to hear you enjoyed your food and service! Thanks for taking the time to review. We hope to see you soon. Regards, Jerry Dicecco Chef/Owner: Jerry & The Mermaid
Some friends and I ate at Jerry & The Mermaid last week. Our server was great (blonde woman)- very nice lady! The food was also really good. I highly reccomend the crab cakes- these were the best crab cakes I have had outside of MD....More
Adriane, I'm glad to hear you enjoyed the crab cakes and the service! I believe Jessica was your server and I'll be sure to compliment her on a job well done. Thank you for dining with us and for taking the time to review. Regards,...More
Stopped for lunch on arrival to Riverhead. Sadly the weather wasn't great but nice view of the inlet with boats. Fish and chips and clams casino were tasty. The clam chowder was delicious.
Shellie, Glad to hear you enjoyed the chowder, clams casino & fish! Three seafood selections for lunch....very awesome! Thanks for the patronage and for the review! We hope to see you soon at Jerry's! Regards, Jerry Dicecco Chef/Owner: Jerry & The Mermaid