The pizza is amazing! Every time we come to New York to visit family this is a must stop. My wife who is from another state absolutely loves this place! I myself have been eating it for years and really like the pizza. I must...More
11 - 20 of 42 reviews
Following a hot day at the beach in Cooperstown, I was hungry, but I knew I didn't want a big meal or anything expensive. I had stopped at NY Pizzeria for the first time in July and enjoyed a meatball tunnel. This time, I ordered...More
DH and I stopped here for a quick bite after a long day in nearby Cooperstown. We ordered garlic knots and Sicilian pizza - both were very good. The place is clean, service is friendly, and prices are reasonable. You place your order at the...More
Small pizzerias can be on the scary side, usually either amazing or downright awful. This one took the cake, I got a large with several toppings and it was baked just the right amount. Didn't take long to make either!
Our pizza was awesome. Ordered a large pizza. It had generous toppings, plenty of cheese. True NY pizza. Service was great. Reasonable prices.
No fancy accommodations, just a clean, fair priced, friendly, mouth-thrilling pizza joint. Some friends and I stopped in to experience this highly favored and well respected local eatery. The recommendation was right on target. The meaty pizza was fulfilling with hand made crust and fresh...More
Loved the home made food, the authentic Italian touch and everything else that comes your way here. The sauce is only like you can remember from Italian neighborhoods in the City as well as the pizza! The meatballs is the best absolute best. Love the...More
This is a nice place which has wifi in an area that generally lacks it. The pizza is excellent but the main attraction is the lovely service here, including a proprietor who remembered my wife's purse when she forgot it.