Recommended by another friend - my buddy and I tried this place. We were both pleasantly surprised with the quality dining experience we had!
1 - 10 of 32 reviews
I went back to Jay's and this time the food was much better. The Mac and Cheese is to die for. Hamburgers are very good,too..Excellent drinks, but a bit expensive.Overall it's been much better after going a few times..
In Oneonta for work and stopped by Jays Place on the recommendation from hotel staff. Small place, right out of the 80s. Don't let that fool you though. Food was Great, as was the service! I got the chicken Florentine and it was delicious. Great...More
Back a year later to eat at Jay's for our 2nd time. Dinner was, once again, outstanding. The restaurant is very small and in a very "strange" location. But once you find it, you will not be disappointed. The artisan bread is exceptional. You could...More
We had dinner here. The food was good, but the bread that was served with our dinner was not very good and the service started out good, but then turned bad. Our server never refilled our drinks and took forever to bring our check and...More
I've been coming here for years. Owners of the place changed every few years and I don't come here enough to be recognized as a "regular", however I am always treated as one even though I only come here about three or four times a...More
We visited this restaurant while our son was playing in a tournament at Cooperstown All Star Village. It was my husband and my 10 year wedding anniversary, and my husband and I decided to take the kids out to eat to have a little celebration....More
I and a friend ordered a prime steak and shrimp dinner. The meat was of low grade very chewy.The dessert was also teriible,,
Nice small steakhouse, varied menu and the owner/chef is very good. Bleu cheese is his own mix and is great. Fish dishes are good and the steaks are cooked to perfection.