It seemed the obvious choice for dinner while staying at the Inn and it did not disappoint. It is very reasonably priced and seems popular as a dining location for local families too. Enjoyed a soup and a hearty burger platter -- good quality and...More

We've been eating as driving here for 45 years, and it just keeps getting better and better. There facility itself is beautiful. The menu is diverse, with more locally grown produce and meats included--fresh, well prepared and delicious. The staff is cheerful and professional. The...More

We had breakfast here and enjoyed the reasonably priced menu. There were more than sufficient options and they even had gluten free bread. Next time we are in town, I'm sure we will stop.

Had a wonderful stay during a snowstorm. Incredibly staff kept the Inn running with wonderful customer service. Bathrooms could use a tune up. Otherwise splendid!

Reliable and friendly over the decades. We were there with a large group over reunion weekend. A good time was had by all.

Very nice place to stay while visiting Colgate Univ. Bathroom and room were both recently updated. Pillows were flat. The food and service downstairs (ate both dinner and breakfast) were not up to standards of the hotel. Not many other options in town, which likely...More

Let me preface by saying that I try to stay at the Colgate Inn about once a year when I visit Hamilton. It's consistently clean, and well maintained. While rooms tend to be small and inexplicably poorly lit, the beds are comfortable and the bar...More

Whether you are just visiting Hamilton because it is lovely, or because you have a child thinking of attending Colgate, this is a wonderful place to stay. The atmosphere is charming, the rooms are luxurious, and the food is delicious.

We have stayed and eaten here many times. The tavern is quite cozy and always busy especially on weekends and when sporting events are going on. The food is consistently good. We really like the the beef and cheddar panini, one of the best sandwiches...More

We stopped at the Colgate Inn after a hockey game (1/21/17). There were eight people and seven of us ordered an alcoholic beverage. For all seven to be served we waited 10-15 minutes. We headed to a lobby area to sit otherwise we'd have had...More