Nice old inn, great location, food really should have been much better. Felt like something you'd get at a chain restaurant, not a nice old inn in a college town.

Nice classic style hotel in center of town. Menu is pretty good, but it can be hit or miss with the quality of the food. I’ve had good meals here before, but this last trip was not memorable. Not many options in town either.

No visit to Hamilton is complete without a visit to this village staple. I especially love the wine flight and the cobb salad and southwest chicken salad.

Dinner here was excellent, had the most tender filet mignon I’ve had in years. My husband had the scallops and were delicious too. Day specials sounded very good too. The chocolate chip pie for dessert is a must. Waiter was very attentive; hostess not so...More

No need to leave the prpoperty for a good meal. The wait staff were friendly and knowledfgable of menu offerings . Willimg to make substitutions .

Reservations were at 7:00pm. The bar was full so we acquired drinks and sat in the lounge area. Staff and manager stopped to ask us if we needed anything and whether we were enjoying ourselves. we were seated at 7 and the waiter immediately told...More

My husband is an alumni of Colgate University and we try to make a football game, basketball game and sometimes a hockey game. We love the Colgate bookstore too! You can bring your sport ticket in to receive a 13% discovery by on one item...More

Enjoyed dinner with friends, everyone shared the appetizers and we so much enjoyed dinner and drinks. The waitress was terrific, I have forgotten her name (sorry) she was very attentive when we needed a refresh of drinks or water. We had a leisure time, it...More

Colgate Inn was highly recommended and food and location did not disappoint. French onion soup was excellent. Good local beer list too.

A lovely old Inn surrounded by the old world charm of beautiful Hamilton NY what more could one ask for ? Amazing food and drinks at the Inns old style pub , excellent formal dinning , a old world private dining room with fireplace and...More