We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Costello's Pizza Emporium - CLOSED

1220 Fairport Rd Ste 2, Fairport, NY 14450-1248
+1 585-586-5300
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent47%
  • Very good23%
  • Average0%
  • Poor15%
  • Terrible15%
14 Jun 2013
“Review some time later ... going downhill”
7 May 2013
“Very good pizza”
Restaurant Hours Closed
Italian, Pizza
1220 Fairport Rd Ste 2, Fairport, NY 14450-1248
All Details
Reviews (13)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 13 reviews

Reviewed 15 June 2013

Since my last rating of Costello's, the experiences have not been good. Chicken/pasta dishes dryer and not flavorful. Very disappointed in getting pizza's the wrong size and burnt on bottom. Hope the downslide doesn't continue.

Thank jrsane
Reviewed 7 May 2013

Had pizza and some beverages recently. Pizza was done perfectly. Had a generous amount of toppings. Draft beers were served in chilled glass. Couldn't ask for anything more. Not a lot of seating inside but comfortable.

Thank Bill B
Reviewed 7 April 2013

This place was awful!!! RUDE waitstaff! The food was disgusting and they were way overpriced! I take my family out weekly for dinner at various restaurants in Fairport and will NEVER return to this poorly run business!

1  Thank Coachmik
Reviewed 8 April 2012

My family and I come here often! I bring friends all the time. I wouldn't ask for anything different. The pizza is delicious; and the service is fantastic! Erik is awesome and always trys to get to know you. Any negative comments here must be...More

Thank Crsx0x
Reviewed 21 February 2012

We have gotten Costello's pizza off and on for years. An order of Mediterranean and a Meat Lover's pizzas is a nice feast . For something different, we ordered some pasta dishes for takeout (Pasta ala Hannah, Chicken Riley and spaghetti for the kid). They...More

Thank jrsane
Reviewed 10 July 2010

Wings were different than I expected (they're sweet, not your traditional buffalo) and available in heat from scorcher to safe for the kiddies. Pizza was also great, though not the NY I love the dough was tasty and everything worked well together. Would go back...More

Thank RightCoastToast
Reviewed 23 January 2010

I grew up a short trip from NYC, with that in mind Costello's is as about as close to home as I can get in the area for a slice of pie. Wings are top notch and I dare you to find a better plate...More

Thank flerg83
Reviewed 4 September 2009

Good wings, great pizza!! Great take-out! Rochester native - and always get dinner here while home!!

Thank wish2trvl
Reviewed 15 March 2009

We went there tonight 3 of us. Pizza was thin and overdone black on bottom. Service was terrible we were there 2 hrs in that time we ordered 2 orders of wings and 2 small pizza's that is how long it took to get our...More

Thank Love2eat50Farmington
Reviewed 8 August 2008

This place is great- they have the best all-you-can eat pizza, wings, pasta and salad special on Saturday nights. The staff is great and the place is cozy. Prices are incredibly cheap. Awesome!

Thank buffalowing
Nearby Restaurants
McArdle's Restaurant
112 reviews
.57 km away
Landmark Family Restaurant
35 reviews
1.45 km away
34 reviews
.00 km away
Fairfields Bar & Grill
33 reviews
.86 km away
Nearby Attractions
Erie Canal
181 reviews
2.00 km away
Painting with a Twist
90 reviews
.26 km away
Big oak Driving Range
5 reviews
2.42 km away
Harris Whalen Park
15 reviews
3.62 km away
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Open Hours
16:00 - 22:00
16:00 - 22:00
11:00 - 14:30
11:00 - 22:00
11:00 - 22:00
11:00 - 22:00
11:00 - 22:30
16:00 - 22:30
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 1220 Fairport Rd Ste 2, Fairport, NY 14450-1248
  • Location: United States  >  New York (NY)  >  Finger Lakes  >  Fairport
  • Phone Number: +1 585-586-5300
Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more. Claim Your Listing