I had read all the reviews which were mixed so I was not sure what to expect when we arrived. It was a Wednesday night in mid September but it was still fairly busy. We started at the bar for some pre dinner drinks where...More
1 - 10 of 261 reviews
One of the best restaurants on Long Island. Understated, but always well done. Food fantastic. Service very good. Nice wine selection. Nice décor. Save room for dessert! A must!
This was our first time dining at Nick & Toni's despite passing by too many times to count! Happily, we were not disappointed! The restaurant is very nicely decorated & comfortable and there is plenty of parking. Our hostess picked out a great table for...More
While you may see a celeb in the summer, Nick & Toni's finds a way to welcome all comers with very good food, strong customer service and a pleasant ambiance. Everything I've ever tried here was delicious.
The food here is mediocre at best. However, I gave 2 stars, because the service is flawless. Once upon a time, this was the hardest table to get in EH; however, this year, it is EMP Summerhouse, which is also DRAMATICALLY over-rated. Moral of the...More
We have had a summer house in Amagansett for 30 years and have been to Nick & Toni's many times and always been pleased. This time it was on our 50th wedding anniversary and to say the least very special to us. My husband's fish...More
Dinner while staying in Montauk with my husband. Food was top knotch from the Caesar, burrata, papperdelle with sagu Ragu was amazing. Coconut gelato with chocolate chunks for dessert was awesome. Not to be missed while in the area. We totally enjoyed it.