We ordered 2 large pizzas for our family and it was way more food than we expected. Very good quality, we will definitely return.
1 - 10 of 61 reviews
Carthage is a quiet place, with not a lot of dining options. So it was a pleasant surprise to find an Italian place down the street with pizza and pasta that could be successful in Brooklyn or Queens or New Haven. The pizza is consistently...More
We ordered the calzone and pizza. The food and service was excellent. I would highly recommend Stefano's for any event.
Tremendous Family Restaurant! Dynamite food, service, and atmosphere. Highly recommend Stefano's for a wide variety of Italian food. We were on a shopping trip and stopped in based on a recommendation - it was all that was described to us and more! You will not...More
For those that don't know Carthage is really God's country. It's in the middle of nowhere. We had been to the family cemetery in Natural Bridge and stopped for a late lunch. Carthage was the nearest place that had a decent restaurant. Everyone ordered something...More
Staying in cabin close by and not many restaurants in this area to choose from for a meal so after reading reviews decided it was better than most other places around here. This place was very busy on Sunday afternoon so service was limited and...More
my husband and I ordered take out from here and we really weren't impressed. The phone call to place our order was painful. He put us on hold to get answers to our questions and asked a lot of questions that seemed obvious like whether...More
I always talk about Cam's, Art's Jug and Stefano's as my favorite upstate pizza joints. Stefano's goes beyond in that they have great wings and Italian fare. Their lasagna is HUGE and unstoppable. Great sandwiches at lunch. And the beautiful thing is, I hit Stefano's...More