A great place to get a seafood bite. Service is quick and the parking lot stays crowded. The food is a tad overpriced but made to perfection! The Pina Coladas are amazing!!!
1 - 10 of 95 reviews
Local favorite of not only City Island but of the people of the Bronx. If you want casual atmosphere, fresh seafood, strong drinks then this is your place. Great fried shrimp - probably the best in the city. One of my favorite places to eat...More
The most minimalist of atmosphere, but the Best in their fried shrimp over French fries & coleslaw, fried lobster tails, calamari, etc... All the best food of 'Sammy's' restaurant without the sky high prices. Did I mention that they Also have The Best tartar sauce...More
I love this place... do not come here if you want fanciful and quiet. Come here for delicious golden fried seafood and the best tartar sauce on earth! Be prepared for craziness especially on weekends. Lines are long, the place is chaotic but I wouldn't...More
First, I love how huge this place is. There is plenty of parking, plenty of seating and the food delivery was lightening fast. I'd like to think it's because they know when their busy times are and so they just keep the food coming. They...More
We love to go to Johnny's and sit outside. Decent, reasonably priced food, a cold beer, and a great waterside view at the tip of the island - one of the highlights of summer.
ok if you go with only fast food seafood in mind, no frills.Also, if there's a crowd, go elsewhere. Some people like to come here and ruin what can be a decent place to grab a quick bite.