You haven't had a bagel unless you've had a Bagelmasters bagel! Expect a line in the morning and around lunch time.
1 - 10 of 21 reviews
It is no doubt bagel masters is an amazing bagel place to get bagels in Shrewsbury. The place can be busy at times but handles the customer's orders super quickly. The place is also cash only, but it's worth it. If you don't want to...More
a very busy place in Shrewsbury with a friendly staff and the best bagels for sure! I usually place an order over the phone so it is ready by the time I get there (line can be loooong)...the bacon egg and cheese on a plain...More
I compare any non-Bagel Master bagels vI have to bagel masters bagels. My kids come home from college and head to bagel masters. There’s usually a line in the mornings around 9 on the weekends. Definitely worth the wait or just visit before 8 or...More
We either get a Bagel, or eat in, most weekends, They have everyone's choice of Bagel or filling. It's a fun place, and the owner is still there everyday, smiling and working hard. I like the All American on a Wholewheat Bagel. But the sliced...More
Located on the corner of White Street and Route 35 in Shrewsbury N.J. made fresh every morning take out or dine in great sandwiches get there early on weekends 7 days a week!!Enjoy!!
Simply the best bagels to be found anywhere. Great cream cheese spreads as well. The service is excellent. Even with long lines the wait is short. Just a great place to take-out or eat-in.
If looking for Fresh Bagels, great service and good prices, look no further than Bagelmasters. You will not be disappointed.
Darren and staff turn out the best bagels in Monmouth County hands down. Their selection of bagel sandwiches, both breakfast and lunch, are unmatched. The line is out the door every weekend. It is worth the wait. Have been a regular since Darren took over...More