Great food better atmosphere and even better BYOB.! Intimate table spacing hard to find in Cape May. Very good service also.
1 - 10 of 809 reviews
Recently attended a small wedding at the Peter Shields Inn and can happily say everything was wonderful. The staff was informed ahead of time that I had an onion allergy and adjustments were made without sacrificing any quality or flavor. Cocktail hour was a lovely...More
We received our dinner as a gift, We can tell you what a gift it was! From the moment we opened the door we were greeted and treated the way you expect at a high end restaurant. We had a beautiful view of the ocean...More
First-rate food, service, and ambiance. The menu had many things I wanted to try, ended up choosing their special tasting menu. Every course was delicious. The beef dish that was one of the courses was slightly overcooked, our server happily took it back and soon...More
Fair, had high expectations, having considered it for a Second Wedding venue 4 years earlier, but chose the Southern Mansion instead. So, off we went with high hopes but left disappointed in the food. The ambiance is outstanding, without question, but the food was mediocre,...More
Thank you for you feedback Mr. Lashendock. We appreciate any sort of feedback and we value our customers opinion. Our Chefs and Staff works hard to make sure all guests meet their expectations and beyond. I am sorry we failed in your case. Your review...More
Delicious meal, with 3 courses and great selection of choices. Server Peter was top notch, Eggs benedict with crabmeat was excellent, as was cheese plate, tuna tartare, asparagus salad. They treated everyone like royalty, was a lovely day. Owner Jeff stopped by table, is a...More
Probably the closest you will get to city quality fine dining (all elements - plenty of excellent food in Cape May, but mostly more casual in their service/decor - which is OK, it's a vacation town). Very refined, but not stuffy. Best bet for a...More
Very good food, correct service, lovely location, A1. Beautiful soup, fish cooked properly, not overcooked. BYOB. Not cheap.
After not having dined at Peter Shields in a number of years, we took our daughter to PS to celebrate her birthday. That experience was so wonderful, my husband and daughter later took me to PS to celebrate my birthday. Again, it could not have...More
Everything was delicious, but it wasn't cheap. Splurge if its a special occasion. We did manage to get in early enough for the prix fix dinner, which provided a relatively excellent value.