There are so many great choices. Flavor is important. You might want to try some of the others first.
1 - 10 of 20 reviews
Went in for lunch, great price for two slices and a drink but the pizza just wasn't as good as I remember. I hadn't been there in several years.
We visit about every other month, and we noticed a "Under New Management" sign. However, the deluxe pizza was wonderful. Lots of fresh vegetables. Local sausage and pepperoni. Crust was great. Staff was friendly and very accommodating. All in all a great meal. Reasonably priced...More
I searched the internet trying to find a "NY" pizza somewhere near me and found Pizzarelli's. Menu wise it looked like I found the deal but was somewhat disappointed when it arrived. They included and charged me for a bottle of soda which I didn't...More
New York style. And they do it right. Never had a slice of NY pizza better in St. Louis. They have a couple of tables but really not a sit down kind of place. The owner is there often and very nice.
You want a giant slice of pizza with the best, freshest cheese around, then look no further! I love that you can go in and order just a slice, or an entire pie! Kiddos love it too. They use a premium cheese and you can...More
I really liked the pizza here even though my wife thought it was only average. My pepperoni and sausage slice was very tasty overall even though I might have preferred the crust to be slightly thinner. You can get slices here of any variety and...More
My very picky son fell in love with NY pizza on a recent vacation, so we went to Pizzarelli's to see how it compared. We both loved it - and it was a bonus that we could order by the slice. The crust was good,...More
Pizza was very good. Should be cooked a few more minutes to get the nice oven taste that one would expect from an advertised "east coast pizza place." But all in all the second best pizza place in the area with good prices.
Been wanting to try their pizza but this trip just got a sandwich which was pretty good pretty big but thought it was about $2 too high in cost at $8.99 I was hoping this was going to be a nice sit down place for...More