Small ice cream cost more than $8. More than we spent in Nantucket. Ice cream was okay but should have been better for that price.
1 - 10 of 124 reviews
We enjoyed this ice cream. It was extremely good. I had pistachio with the free sprinkles. I can only say great things about the cleanliness, service, and taste. I did take 1 star away only because of the price. We bought 4 small ice cream...More
Ok so what's not to like about ice cream? Well according to some the price. We sat outside last night and witness two people leave without ice cream talking about the how ridiculous the price is and another couple with ice cream muttering "rip off"....More
We have travelling around New England for the last 5 weeks and tried quality ice cream throughout our travels. The salted caramel was superb and was on a par with one of the best I have tasted. My husband loved the peach flavour. Expensive but...More
There is nearly always a line to get in, but the service is prompt and the ice cream is outstanding. This is a staple of Chatham!!
It is a delicious treat, more expensive I suppose than other places, but we have paid some crazy prices for good ice cream in Italy too. In a way it is good for a portion control ...one pretty big scoop is enough. The hard part...More
It was empty when we went in so we were served promptly, the lady was a bit surly, but the ice cream was fabulous, the pumpkin flavour was tremendous. We sat out the back on the benches and enjoyed it thoroughly.