I know that pizza can be subjective, but I believe that Goodfellas has some of the best pizza around.
1 - 10 of 120 reviews
I believe this is the first location in Lexington. It is downtown and they have excellent pizza. The only issue is there is basically no seating, maybe a few spots inside and two tables on the sidewalk.
Pro: The atmosphere is great. It's an industrial vibe and tall ceilings. You can go in and out as you please. The outdoor area has bocci ball set, a fire pit, and nice seating. Great area to enjoy a drink outside. Con: The service wasn't...More
Price is good! It was always packed! A little bit of everyone was heading In: locals, teenagers, families, college kids. One breadstick is the length of your arm! One piece of pizza is gigantic! Flavor is good but not the best I've ever had. But...More
Ive eaten A LOT of pizza in my life and this pizza was very good. We ordered plain old plain, take out. The pros: this pizza WAS delicious and it would pass for NY pizza especially in a southern city like Lexington, but being from...More
My daughter was a regular here during her time in Lexington. I have eaten there twice and I agree with her that it is some of the best pizza I have ever had. The staff has always been friendly and helpful. She is going to...More
We stopped in here for lunch. The special was a large slice of pizza, salad and a craft beer all for 6 bucks. Really good pizza.
ordered takeout on several occasions during business trip. very consistently good. plenty of cheese and toppings, crust is excellent and portions are amazing! definitely would recommend.